Blog

Impact wrench VS Impact driver | Get your perfect one

Impact wrench VS Impact driver

Have you ever faced any problem while loosening the eroded screws in their right position? Well, In this case we need the help of best tools to get the job done perfectly. A perfect impact driver or impact wrench can be our best pick in such situation. These two actually come with the perfect torque for completing several applications smoothly

In the back, the two power-wrenching options for impact drivers were regular electric drill and torque wrench. The electric drill was for general driving and drilling while on the other hand the torque wrench was for automotive repairing.

After that the compact, handy yet more powerful impact drivers came into being which stood out the market with its user-friendliness. People found a more convenient and light machine.

If you want to trace the differences between these two, you will find these two almost the same apart from a few differences. If you would like to get the top performance out of these necessary tools, you need to know the differences precisely. Down below, impact wrench VS impact driver and some definite situations of these tools’ effective performance will be our main discussion.

Impact  Driver  vs  impact  Wrench; What’s Your Pick ???

Impact  Driver  vs  impact  Wrench; What’s Your Pick ???

In comparison to weight, impact wrenches are more powerful because they are heavier and they can put into more torque than impact drivers.

  • ​Buyers guide

Impact wrench is one of the most important tools for a shop, a garage or even a professional. Here you will find a short list of suitable impact wrenches within a suitable range of price. The wrenches, which are of pro-quality may cost between $150 to $300 and may be suitable for average users.

top 3 Best Impact wrenches

  • ​DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless impact wrench
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

One thing you will be assuring aboutDeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless impact wrench is  that it comes with killer power. This impact wrench takes the compact and lightweight design into a new level. What’s more, it follows the trend of appealing build quality with a clever touch of styles which resemblance only a brand who knows what needs to include to make tools excellent. Moreover, this tool allows you to tighten the nuts effortlessly and without using much effort.

This DCF880HM2 tool boasts with a superior-quality construction and excellent performance. The price tag is not so convenient compare to the other cordless impact wrenches on the market but still you’ll get decent amount of features and user-friendly design. The fact is, it’s the best option whether you are a motorist or driver because with this tool you’ll be able to change the wheel in a matter of second.

Despite being compact and lightweight, this tool is durable and strong also. Without any damage, it can last for many years. Undoubtedly, this is one of those tools that can take dozen of beating and just keep going. Even it has a decent battery life that can easily monitor using the fuel gauge. However, the 2 batteries can make your life easier. Whether one runs out in the halfway in your job, you have the option to reload and get into the work straightly. What’s more, each can last for 4amp hours and charge quickly-means you will hardly find yourself without power. As claimed by the manufacturer, this tool offers 33% more power than the other power tools on the market.

It features 3 LED lights with 20-second delay after trigger release. Regardless of this problem of waiting, you will be able to finish any kind of work in tight or dark spaces. However, having 3 lights give you full illumination so there are no shadow. Moreover, you don’t get any limitation while using it and it’s the main reason behind its popularity.

​PROS
  • ​Superbly portable and lightweight.
    Superbly portable and lightweight
  • ​User-friendly.
    User-friendly
  • ​3-LED lights
    3-LED lights
  • check-square
    ​2 XR Li-Ion batteries ensures 33% more power.
    2 XR Li-Ion batteries ensures 33% more power
​CONS
  • ​Not suitable for beginner level user as its comes with immense of power.
    Not suitable for beginner level user as its comes with immense of power
  • ​Who Should Buy?
    Who Should Buy?
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless impact wrench is impress their consumers by their dominant performance and quality. Light yet comprised with enough power so that comfortably take any kind of jobs. Especially remodelling cars, maintaning and repairing vehicles even tinkering with truck etc.

  • ​Ingersoll-Rand 231C super duty air impact wrench
    Ingersoll-Rand 231C
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

This Ingersoll Rand 231C 1/2-Inch Super-Duty Air Impact Wrench is another tool to watch out! It comes with the power required to easily handle those stubborn rusty nuts off.Lightweight, compact and superior quality makes it a great tool for all day use.Truly,its hold the title of the best seller on number of platforms. However, it’s a must have tools for any vehicle hobbyist and professional mechanics.

Not really every kind of work needs same amount of power, but fortunately with an impact wrench you have adjustable power facilities. The 231C from Ingersoll Rand offers you sheer number of power for your tough jobs. Its design helps you to attain balance results every time you work with it. With regulator system, it directs full power in one direction and variable power in other. This means it you’re independent to set the power. If you want to achieve full power in all directions, simply rotate the reverse system until you reach 5.

Even this impact wrench comprised with unique impact mechanism which actually differ it from other impact wrenches on the market. Meaning you can use ½-inch every time you work on a project. This quality makes this tool a have to product in your shop. However, other impact wrenches might provides similar features but the mechanism on this unit is exclusively find in Ingersoll Rand brand. Most importantly, this durable tool delivers a maximum torque 600ft./lbs and an impressive  speed of 8,000 rpm for efficient and fast performance. Not just that this tool boasts an average air consumption of 4.2 CFM.

If you want an impact wrench work perfectly, it requires right lubrications. In most power tools on the market it’s become difficult to achieve the right lubrication due to the quality and design. But while you using Ingersoll Rand 231C; you don’t need to worry at all.This manufacturer introduces this 2-piece design tool for easy and fast lubrication.

​PROS
  • ​Rotating system its look like a breeze
    Rotating system its look like a breeze
    Superbly portable and lightweight
  • ​Excellent impact force.
    Excellent impact force
    User-friendly
  • ​Incredibly portable only 5.5 pounds.
    Incredibly portable only 5.5 pounds
    3-LED lights
  • check-square
    ​Worthy to the investment.
    Worthy to the investment
    2 XR Li-Ion batteries ensures 33% more power
​CONS
  • ​Some users find problem with the instruction.
    Some users find problem with the instruction
  • thumbs-down
    ​Pretty loud.
    Pretty loud
  • ​Who Should Buy?
    Who Should Buy?
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

This one is a versatile tool which can handle any kind of tasks. Combined everything, this is a perfect choice for home and outdoor use.

  • ​​Porter-Cable PCE210 impact wrench
    Porter-Cable PCE210
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

If you have something to look forward to, then you can definitely go with Porter-Cable PCE210. This efficient yet affordable impact wrench was launched recently with Hog Ring Anvil attachment.Look at the specifications along with the price tag; you would not like anything other than this stylish and unique impact wrench. As it’s corded, it will not let you feel the convenience you find with a cordless tool. But what more you can expect from a $100 impact wrench? The power of nearly 3,000 in. lbs of torque makes it a pretty good deal.

In concerning the size, this impact wrench is quite heavy in compare to the other tools in this list. Other than that what you expect from a tools coming with superior-quality construction? More to that, this one is nicely balanced the quality so that the weight can distribute perfectly.As result you can easily control the tools at the same time minimize fatigue regardless the weight.

For more productivity and faster speed it has boasts with 2,200 RPM.At highest speed, this impact wrench begins gather whopping2,700 impacts per minutes. Even it is capable of delivering 240 foot-pounds of torque to match any heavy-duty applications. Combine all these excellent features glorify Porter-Cable PCE210 as a tool of fast speed applications. However, this tool has durable and longer life as it comprise with cast metal gear housing. This material helps to scatter heat which adds more years to the motor.

A non-slip handle with rubber coating allow you to experience an ergonomic grip that is soft and easy in your hand. In traditional way the switch is situated in the handle and allows you adjust the power with ease.A hole comes in the bottom of the handle to keep away all the debris. Moreover, the vibration level is not too much so you wouldn’t feel tired while using it.

​PROS
  • ​Solid manufacture quality.
    Solid manufacture quality
    Superbly portable and lightweight
  • ​5-amp  superior-duty motor.
    5-amp  superior-duty motor
    User-friendly
  • check-square
    ​Cast metal gear housing scatter heats.
    Cast metal gear housing scatter heats
    2 XR Li-Ion batteries ensures 33% more power
  • check-square
    ​Easier to store.
    Easier to store
  • check-square
    ​Suitable for all kind of functions.
    Suitable for all kind of functions
  • check-square
    ​Significantly reasonable price.
    Significantly reasonable price
​CONS
  • ​Quite heavy for one hand operation.
    Quite heavy for one hand operation
  • ​Who Should Buy?
    Who Should Buy?
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

The price range and quality of this tool is quite impressive. It delivers enough motor power for heavy-duty applications. As it’s a corded tool so it’s a great choice for any professionals or weekend warriors who actually don’t travel a lot.

The price range and quality of this tool is quite impressive. It delivers enough motor power for heavy-duty applications. As it’s a corded tool so it’s a great choice for any professionals or weekend warriors who actually don’t travela lot.

top 3 Best Impact ​ drivers

  • ​Makita XDT111 impact driver
    Makita XDT111 impact driver
    Porter-Cable PCE210
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

While presented in a compact size, the Makita XDT111 impact driver nicely delivers a solid level of power and speed for your needs. As it comes with a portable size, it gives you a simple and easier experience whenever you drive bolts or fasten various materials.In consider performance you will be slightly disappointed compared to the previous one but wisely it’s a fantastic tool at an attractive price tag.

1,500 in lbs of torque are enough for you if you are not opting for a huge automotive work.

This Makita impact driver is very popular among the automobile industry. It sports an18V LXT lithium-ion battery that leads to very little downtime for greater efficiency. At this power, it can deliver a decent amount of torque of 1,460 in. lbs. which is more than enough for anyone. In fact this model is one of the most powerful impact drivers in this review. Even it can deliver 2times more power than other drill driver. Moreover, you can use this tool for fasten bolts in any kind of hard materials for instance hardwood or even can use it as a regular drill driver.

Perhaps most significantly, it just performs really well. With variable speed motor that offers this tool to do a speed of 0-2,900 RPM 0-3,500 RPM. You can easily change the speed with a push of a button, easy and simple to operate.

Another great thing of XDT111 is we can expect from other power tools– its Makita’s XPT Extreme Protection Technology. It’s kind of protective layer that this brand had so that the water and extra dust can’t reach into the internals of this driver.

Further more, you can buy this tool in three choice options. Either only the impact driver or get the other option that comprised with 38 piece drill bit set with a holder. Even for more versatility, you can purchase the most expensive type which contains 70-piece drill bit set.Although, we recommend this option only to professionals.

​PROS
  • ​Ergonomic and lightweight.
    Ergonomic and lightweight
    Solid manufacture quality
    Superbly portable and lightweight
  • ​Excellent price range .
    Excellent price range
    5-amp  superior-duty motor
    User-friendly
  • check-square
    Comprised with XPT Extreme Protection Technology.
    Comprised with XPT Extreme Protection Technology
    Cast metal gear housing scatter heats
    2 XR Li-Ion batteries ensures 33% more power
  • check-square
    Rubberized soft grip.
    Rubberized soft grip
    Easier to store
​CONS
  • Cheaper exterior design.
    Cheaper exterior design
    Quite heavy for one hand operation
  • ​Who Should Buy?
    Who Should Buy?
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

Makita XDT111 impact driver is very affordable and considering the most powerful tool in this list. Delivers 1,460 in. lbs. of torque means its more than enough for any general automobile work or home use.

  • Milwaukee 2656-21 M18 cordless impact driver
    Milwaukee 2656-21 M18 cordless
    Porter-Cable PCE210
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

Whether you are a professional contractor with heavy-duty work on a daily basis or homeowner who likes DIY projects for the Milwaukee 2656-21 M18 cordless impact driver is rightly the best option to pick.

Milwaukee’s M18 batteries are quite famous for their amazing performance, with the lightning-fast charging feature and will serve better than any other driver available. In fact, their M18 boast with ergonomic design and state-of-art technology. A torque of almost 2,200 in. lbs make it an amazing, delightful and user-friendly machine.

This impact driver has comes with many impressive features that can help you in your home projects or heavy duty jobs around the construction sites. Undoubtedly, one of the best impact drivers in its class and it’s power ration sure to surprise you. Packed with almost 2200in. lbs. of torque is great for driving thick or long screws. It’s also perfect for home repair or improvement jobs such as mounting TVor CCTV camera. Simply it’s perfect for any project that need repetitive fastening and screwing for a long period of time.

This impact driver has comes with many impressive features that can help you in your home projects or heavy duty jobs around the construction sites. Undoubtedly, one of the best impact drivers in its class and it’s power ration sure to surprise you. Packed with almost 2200in. lbs. of torque is great for driving thick or long screws. It’s also perfect for home repair or improvement jobs such as mounting TVor CCTV camera. Simply it’s perfect for any project that need repetitive fastening and screwing for a long period of time.

The design of 2656-21 is lightweight and compact, making it suitable for cramped and tight spaces. In fact,work on those awkward places is very easy with this impact driver. Measuring only 5.5 inches means it’s quite small in size and not causes any strains in your arms, wrist or hand while you use it in double times.

However, Milwaukee’s M18 batteries are known as the best of the best. Interestingly, this tool contains 18v M18 lithium-ion battery that can also use on the other power tool of M18 category.In fact, this can be a great purchase for those to have other M18 tools. Moreover, the battery is also very lightweight so it does barely add weight.

​PROS
  • ​Gives 3200 IPM.
    Gives 3200 IPM
    Solid manufacture quality
    Superbly portable and lightweight
  • ​Built-in LED light.
    Built-in LED light
    5-amp  superior-duty motor
    User-friendly
  • check-square
    ​Battery fuel gauge indicator.
    Battery fuel gauge indicator
    Cast metal gear housing scatter heats
    2 XR Li-Ion batteries ensures 33% more power
  • check-square
    ​Lightweight and compact.
    Lightweight and compact
    Easier to store
​CONS
  • ​Sold as a bare tool.
    Sold as a bare tool.
    Quite heavy for one hand operation
  • ​Who Should Buy?
    Who Should Buy?
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

​Actually, Milwaukee 2656-21 M18 cordless impact driver isrank high among its class. Made with superior quality technology, this impact driver is perfect for both professionals and DIY users.

•    Actually, Milwaukee 2656-21 M18 cordless impact driver isrank high among its class. Made with superior quality technology, this impact driver is perfect for both professionals and DIY users.
  • ​DeWalt DCF885C1 impact driver
    DeWalt DCF885C1 impact driver
    Milwaukee 2656-21 M18 cordless
    Porter-Cable PCE210
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

The DeWalt DCF885C1 impact driver is a fantastic buy for the beginner level users because its compact builds quality able to experience you lightweight body.A compact 1.5 amp 20V MAX battery costing such a low price is definitely amazing. A single charge won’t let you deal with your heavy duties. So if you think it won’t suit you, you will have an option for the bigger 4.0 amp batteries, which will give you a torque of about 1,400 in. lbs. Mostly a cordless impact driver is much preferable because it can use in different places without dragging the long cords. Regardless of all the features, it has, this power tool is a great purchase.

An extremely powerful impact driver means it can be used in wide array of tasks. Such as, it can be used in simple attachment or removal of your car lug nuts. Make sure you hold the tool firmly especially on the wood to avoid slipping. Also, the tool needs to hold tightly to stay on the screw head in place. As this tool delivers 1400 inches per lb. of torque so it allows removing the stuck screws as well as inserting screws into the hard materials.

Weighing less than 3 pounds and measurement is just over 5.5 inches wide, 9 inches tall and 3 inches thick, makes it a small and lightweight tool.Its sleek design fit nicely into the user’s hand. Actually, this power tool can give you pleasant surprise, for instance, easy to carry and lightweight quality. As it comes in lightweight feature so it can protect users from pain and injuries also.

Another great feature of this tool is the control of the speed. It can be controlled by the amount of the pressure of the trigger. The speed will increase based on the force of your finger you trigger. Even this allows users to quickly change the speed base on your requirement.

​PROS
  • ​Lightweight only 2.8 pounds.
    Lightweight only 2.8 pounds
    Gives 3200 IPM
    Solid manufacture quality
    Superbly portable and lightweight
  • ​LED lights for improve visibility.
    LED lights for improve visibility
    Built-in LED light
    5-amp  superior-duty motor
    User-friendly
  • check-square
    ​1400lbs of torque power.
    1400lbs of torque power
    Battery fuel gauge indicator
    Cast metal gear housing scatter heats
    2 XR Li-Ion batteries ensures 33% more power
  • check-square
    ​Great price range.
    Great price range
    Lightweight and compact
    Easier to store
​CONS
  • ​Some users complain about the battery’s longevity. But it totally depends on your using.
    Some users complain about the battery’s longevity. But it totally depends on your using.
    Sold as a bare tool.
    Quite heavy for one hand operation
  • ​Who Should Buy?
    Who Should Buy?
    DeWalt DCF880HM2 cordless

​Its small size and manageable weight can able to operate both men and women and it’s the biggest selling point of this tool. The quality is really appreciable and the price makes it more than worthy.

Its small size and manageable weight can able to operate both men and women and it’s the biggest selling point of this tool. The quality is really appreciable and the price makes it more than worthy.

What are  impact  wrenches  used  for?

The basic work is to loosen or tighten bolts and screws. These wrenches basically use ¼” hex drive and ½” square drive. You can use an adaptor to convert between the two drives. It always sets a mechanical advantage no matter the type of bolts you are working with

How much powerful impact wrenches are compared to impact drivers?

To be precise, the impact wrenches are lot more powerful than impact drivers we use. An example can best suit for the reader’s understanding. The Milwaukee M18 ½” impact wrench is one of the most powerful ones because it roughly delivers a torque of roughly 13,000 lbs which is more way better than a driver.

The amount of torque we are discussing are simply useless for in-house jobs, unless you are working on a truck in your compound. Impact drivers come out nicely to accomplish the job efficiently in comparison to standard drills. But when it comes down to drilling holes or driving bolts, impact wrenches will be outrageous. In the automobile shops, where loosening huge, highly tightened sockets often produce supersonic, high pitched drilling noise, these high performance impact wrenches are used there almost exclusively.

While you are using a regular socket wrench in order to loosen a stuck bolt, you may not remove it on your own. So you will require a hammer, with which you will slightly strike the bolt and it will automatically become loose. If you have no idea how impact wrench and driver works, this is how they are driven. Unlike just spinning of the regular drills, they function in the same way of delivering cyclic blows in order to maximize the torque. Go through the below passage to learn more in details about impact wrench VS impact driver.

  • Handlin​g to it

Yeah! Handling is one very critical factor to concentrate when you are going to learn about impact wrench VS impact driver. The impact wrench is large in general, that's why it gets very difficult to handle for several users. If the size would be smaller, many people would find it comfortable to use. Those who are used to work in single hand, they would feel comfortable to use the smaller one. So, impact driver is a definite option for those sort of people.

  • ​there noise

Usually, the impact wrenches are prone to produce a remarkable amount of noise. We found some cases where users are strictly instructed to wear the earplugs while operating an impact wrench, cause of they are exposed to high pitched noise. On the contrary, the impact drivers are quiet enough. So, they do not produce noise at the disturbing level which usually raise concerns. It's up on you what tools are going to pick for you.

  • ​power source options

Understanding of how this machine is driven can make much easier to use and handle the tools. Especially before using the machine for various type of applications. Here, both machines come to us with a variety of power source options. In case of impact wrench, the compressed air is used as the power source of it. In the other hand, the impact driver's power source are different. They usually uses electricity as the main power source for all type of operations.

  • ​when to use what

Like we said earlier, if you are an average user or a DIYer you won’t need the aid of the impact wrench. You can easily deal with the simple mechanical jobs or in-house works like displacing draw nuts without the help of an impact wrench. So if you are not interested to waste your money, you can try a lug wrench.

But the impact drivers are really useful for general use, and they are more popular too. How was it possible? It’s because they give a compact performance and provides more torque compared to a regular standard drill as well. But unlike an impact wrench, they are pretty much user-friendly. And the only use you can have with an impact wrench, displacing draw nuts from the cars can also be done with most of the impact drivers available in the market.

Last Words

In between the competition to impact wrench VS impact driver, the impact wrenches scored way too more than impact drivers because they are much powerful. If you are not an automobile mechanic or if you don’t have to deal with heavy jobs, you may not require uses of high torque. In comparison, impact drivers will very much suit the average users.

Brandon Cooper
the authorBrandon Cooper
This website is developed and supported by me who has been a passionate lover of power and automotive tools. I dedicate my home improvement projects in both DIY and professional type of person. I am an enthusiast and love to share what I know about this field.

Leave a Reply